Judith on a Pasta Label: Must be sauce to lose your head over

There has been a news story doing the rounds about a pasta label that uses a depiction of Jewish heroine Judith:


The pasta sauce has caused quite a stir. The objection is that “the image, as Middle Earth Organics would know if anyone had done ANY research whatsoever, is Judith Beheading Holofernes, a 1598 painting by Caravaggio. Judith … is not making an al dente delight. Judith is cutting off some dude’s head.”

Here is the full painting from which the pasta label was taken:


The story then suggests that the pasta makers should have consulted “an art history major”. Well, perhaps.

But the use of Judith the beheader is actually quite appropriate for marketing pasta sauce.

In the Book of Judith, the heroine Judith takes her own Jewish food to eat while she stays with Holofernes: wine, oil, barley groats, figcakes, white bread, and (in some versions) cheese.

According to a tradition that began in the Middle Ages, Judith attempted to get Holofernes drunk by giving him wine, and tried to get him drowsy (or thirsty) by offering him her cheese. By incapacitating Holofernes with her own delicious food and drink, she was then able to cut off his head. The tradition provides an explanation why cheese is eaten at the festival of Hanukkah.

And of course, what’s a pasta without a bit of grated cheese on top? Some tasty pecorino romano would go nicely.

So the pasta label in fact seems rather apt… if not to an art historian, at least to a biblical reception historian.

Judith, by Katy Wiedemann
Judith, by Katy Wiedemann

3 thoughts on “Judith on a Pasta Label: Must be sauce to lose your head over

  1. Well, I just learned I was supposed to eat cheese at Hanukkah. What?

    You are right on the Biblical stuff in THEORY.

    However, THIS image REMAINS a painting of a woman killing a man by cutting off his head with her bare hands!

    It wasn’t Judy having fun while hanging out with the man who wanted and was KILLING her FELLOW JEWS.

    She is JUDITH, seductress turned murderess to FREE her ppl! She is a FIERCE warrior. Not a cook!

    It’s the face of FEMALE ENRAGEMENT! Taking matters into her own hands. The men were helpless.

    RISKING her life! HER LIFE is at stake. Any minute her life could be over.

    THAT is THE look on her face.

    Maybe you gotta be a woman to see and feel THIS side of the story.

    That’s why using THIS Biblical character (a Hebrew aka Jew) to sell ITALIAN sauce is adding outrage to the story.

    This is a WOMAN’s Story. Busting OUT OF the kitchen, into the battlefield. Becoming a legendary heroine to women and Jews. And obviously, artists love the story too.

    Thanks for reminding me of the deets. I knew she seduced him with food and wine to set him up for the kill. She was SMART, planned it and was prepared.

    I love how you told it. EXCEPT this painting is about a FURIOUS woman MURDERING her people’s killer. Shalom.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s